Skip to main content
FMLY5-min read

No Bad Kids: Toddler Discipline Without Shame

By Janet Lansbury

#Toddler discipline#Respectful parenting#RIE#Boundaries#Emotional regulation#Gentle Parenting

Section 1: Analysis & Insights

Executive Summary​

Thesis: Toddlers are not "bad" or manipulative; they are little scientists testing boundaries. Discipline means "to teach," not to punish. The most effective tool is a calm, unruffled leader who sets firm limits while accepting all feelings.

Unique Contribution: Lansbury brings Magda Gerber's RIE (Resources for Infant Educarers) philosophy to the toddler years. She reframes "misbehavior" as a request for leadership. Her "Unruffled" concept is a game-changer for parents who feel triggered by tantrums.

Target Outcome: A relationship based on respect and trust, where the child feels safe enough to express feelings but secure enough to follow limits.

Chapter Breakdown​

  • The Mindset: Why toddlers test limits (it's their job).
  • The Method: How to set limits with respect (no time-outs, no shame).
  • The Practice: Specific scripts for hitting, biting, eating, and sleeping.
  • The Leader: How to cultivate "Confident Momentum."

Nuanced Main Topics​

The "Unruffled" Parent​

Toddlers need a sturdy leader, not a peer who falls apart when they cry. Being "unruffled" doesn't mean being robotic; it means having a high tolerance for their chaos. If you react with anger, you give them too much power. They need to know you can handle their big feelings without crumbling.

Sportscasting (Narrating)​

Instead of judging ("Be nice!"), simply narrate what is happening ("You want the toy. Billy has the toy. You are frustrated."). This validates the child's experience and slows down the interaction, giving everyone time to think. It teaches emotional intelligence by labeling the reality.

"I Won't Let You"​

This is the golden phrase. Instead of pleading ("Please stop hitting"), state the boundary as a fact of your leadership: "I won't let you hit me." Then, use your hands to gently block the hit. It is active, confident, and non-shaming.

Acknowledging Feelings vs. Permitting Behavior​

You can accept the feeling ("You are so mad I said no to the cookie") while holding the boundary ("We are still having dinner first"). Most parents mix these up—they either give in to stop the crying (permissive) or punish the crying (authoritarian). Lansbury says: Keep the boundary, welcome the tears.

Section 2: Actionable Framework

The Checklist​

  • Shift Mindset: "Testing is not bad; it's a question."
  • Check Tone: Am I asking ("Okay?") or telling ("It's time")?
  • Remove "No": Use positive limits ("Walk please" vs. "Don't run").
  • Sportscast: Narrate conflicts before intervening.
  • Hands On: Be close enough to physically block hitting.
  • Accept Meltdowns: Don't try to fix/stop the crying. Just listen.

Implementation Steps (Process)​

Process 1: The "Unruffled" Limit Setting​

Purpose: Stop behavior without shame.

Steps:

  1. Spot: You see the hand raising to hit.
  2. Block: Gently catch the hand. (Do not squeeze or hurt).
  3. State: "I won't let you hit." (Calm, factual tone).
  4. Acknowledge: "You are angry that I took the toy."
  5. Hold: "I'm going to hold your hands until you are safe."

Process 2: Sportscasting a Sibling Fight​

Purpose: Teach conflict resolution.

Steps:

  1. Observe: Don't rush in unless safety is at risk.
  2. Narrate: "Johnny, you have the truck. Sarah, you want the truck."
  3. Wait: Give them space to solve it.
  4. Guide: If it escalates, "I won't let you grab. Johnny is using it. You can ask him for a turn."
  5. Comfort: If Sarah cries, "It's hard to wait. You really want it." (Do not force Johnny to share).

Process 3: The "Confident Momentum" Transition​

Purpose: Moving a stuck toddler.

Steps:

  1. Announce: "It is time to go to the car."
  2. Wait: Give a moment for processing.
  3. Choice: "Do you want to walk, or shall I carry you?"
  4. Act: If they dawdle/ignore, saying "I see you need help." Then gently pick them up and move. (No anger, just momentum).
  5. Accept: If they kick/scream, "You didn't want to leave. I hear you." Keep moving.

Process 4: The Mealtime Boundary​

Purpose: End food battles.

Steps:

  1. Serve: Provide healthy food.
  2. Trust: Let them eat how much they want.
  3. Observe: If they throw food, "I won't let you throw."
  4. Consequence: If they do it again, "It looks like you are done." Remove the food calmly.
  5. No Snacks: If they whine later, "Kitchen is closed. Breakfast is in the morning." (Hunger is a natural consequence, not a punishment).

Common Pitfalls​

  • Reacting: Yelling "STOP IT!" (This scares them or excites them, but doesn't teach).
  • Pleading: "Please eat your peas for Mommy?" (Giving away your power).
  • Distracting: "Look at the birdie!" (Disrespects their feelings).
  • Time-Outs: Sending them away when they are having a hard time. ( abandonment).